Skip to content
ListingMinds
ListingMinds

Battery storage · Field note

NYSERDA’s standard bulk storage contract settles against a market index, not the battery’s own revenue

NYSERDA’s standard contract for bulk storage hedges a project against a market index of energy and capacity prices, not against the battery’s own revenue. Its credits follow the availability a project achieves, month by month, not the 95% at which every bid was evaluated.

ListingMinds · Published and updated · Sources verified

Geography: United States, New York · Procurement rounds covered: US New York ISCRFP25-1, closed

On this page

The standard-form agreement of NYSERDA’s first bulk storage round buys no electricity, capacity or ancillary services from the batteries it covers. It settles the difference between the strike price the developer bid and a market reference price, on every credit the project creates. The form hedges a project against a market index, not against its own trading result.1, 4, 5

NYSERDA, the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority, announced the eight projects of that round, ISCRFP25-1, on .1 It had received bid proposals for 46 eligible projects, “totaling roughly 6 gigawatts of power capacity and 30 gigawatt-hours of energy storage capacity”.2 Payments do not begin until a project has begun commercial operation, NYSERDA’s announcement says, and all eight are expected to be in service by the end of 2030.1

The terms below are those of the published standard form: the RFP provided for edits to it before a conformed draft was signed, short of the strike price, so a signed contract may differ in places. None of the signed contracts was among the documents read.

A strike price against an index, settled in both directions

The credit is the Index Storage Credit (ISC): one MWh of discharge capability per day, so a fully available 20 MW / 80 MWh project creates 80 ISCs a day. Each ISC is settled monthly at the strike price minus a reference price built from NYISO energy arbitrage and capacity prices: when the strike price is higher, NYSERDA pays the developer the difference; when the reference price is higher, the developer pays NYSERDA. The RFP presents this as greater revenue certainty for project owners: the strike price is meant to approximate what a project needs to be viable, the reference price what it could reasonably earn in those markets under typical operations, and projects are not required to take part in them. A battery that trades better than the index keeps the difference; one that trades worse is not made whole for the shortfall.4

When the reference price is the higher, the standard form limits a month’s debit to the strike price × that month’s ISCs: the developer never owes more per credit than the strike price itself. Nor is the debit due in cash at once: under the form, NYSERDA pays nothing that month, records the debit and deducts it from its later payments, and the developer pays in cash only what is still unrecovered after 12 months, or at the end of the contract delivery term. The programme’s Implementation Plan describes the same limit. 5, 6 The RFP itself printed a different formula for that cap, the strike price × the bid power capacity × the hours in the month.4 The standard form, for its part, states that it supersedes all prior agreements and understandings on its subject.5

The strike price is binding as bid: the RFP says NYSERDA cannot change it through edits to the agreement. It can still move: before award NYSERDA kept the right to ask for revised strike prices, and the standard form adjusts it in set cases, among them those in the table.4, 5

Some of the standard form’s adjustments to the strike price
WhenEffect on the strike price
An alternate bid opted into the component cost indices adjustmentRevised once before the contract delivery term starts, by no more than 12% up or down
A change in law on construction codes would raise the strike price by more than 5%Raised by the amount above 5%, at most 5%
The project obtains financing from or supported by the US Department of Energy’s Loan Programs OfficeReduced by 1%
The seller or an affiliate receives qualifying governmental support: tax or other direct financial benefits for energy infrastructure under a statute enacted after the bid price submission date, or grant funding other than what the bid expected and disclosed (not ordinary course tax deductions or research grants)Reduced

Source: NYSERDA’s ISCRFP25-1 RFP and its standard form agreement.4, 5

Evaluated at 95% availability, settled on what the project achieves

Under the standard form, NYSERDA buys ISCs only if the facility reaches at least 95% of its bid power capacity and of its bid storage duration at commercial operation, achieved by the milestone date and with Operational Certification. From then on, a month’s ISCs are its bid power capacity × its bid storage duration, counted up to 8 hours, × the days in the month, scaled down by the share of the month’s capacity lost to outages. Outages shrink the hedge in both directions: fewer credits mean a smaller payment in a month NYSERDA pays, and a smaller debit in a month the developer owes.5

Every bid was evaluated at an assumed availability of 95%, with a contract delivery term starting in for every project not yet operating, whatever its proposed commercial operation date. Each strike price was converted into a levelized net cost per ISC by subtracting NYSERDA’s own forecasts of the reference energy arbitrage and capacity prices. A project on the standard form, by contrast, settles on the availability it achieves and the reference prices the market produces.4

Worked exampleISCs from one hypothetical project in one month, at three levels of availabilityBefore any price is applied, the hypothetical project creates 12,000 ISCs in a fully available month, 11,400 at 95% availability, the level the round’s evaluation assumed for every bid, and 10,800 at 90%. Each ISC is then settled at the strike price minus the reference price, paid by NYSERDA when the result is positive and by the developer when it is negative. The example counts ISCs, not money, and not the project’s own market revenues.Show the calculation
Worked exampleISCs from one hypothetical project in one month, at three levels of availabilityOne hypothetical project of 100 MW and 4 hours, in a 30-day month of 720 hours. Only the outage MWh change between the three cases.
Published values
ISCs per MWh of discharge capability per dayISC 14
Duration counted towards ISCs, at most8 hours5
Availability assumed in the round’s price evaluation95 %4
Assumptions
Hypothetical bid power capacity100 MW
Hypothetical bid storage duration4 hours
Days in the month30 days
Hours in the month720 hours
Outage in case B3,600 MWh
Outage in case C7,200 MWh
Calculation
StepCalculationResult
Maximum ISCs in the month100 MW × 4 hours × 30 days12,000 ISCs
Case A: no outage12,000 × 100%12,000 ISCs
Case B: availability1 − 3,600 MWh ÷ (100 MW × 720 hours)95 %
Case B: ISCs12,000 × 95%11,400 ISCs
Case C: availability1 − 7,200 MWh ÷ (100 MW × 720 hours)90 %
Case C: ISCs12,000 × 90%10,800 ISCs

Result. Before any price is applied, the hypothetical project creates 12,000 ISCs in a fully available month, 11,400 at 95% availability, the level the round’s evaluation assumed for every bid, and 10,800 at 90%. Each ISC is then settled at the strike price minus the reference price, paid by NYSERDA when the result is positive and by the developer when it is negative. The example counts ISCs, not money, and not the project’s own market revenues.

Method. Monthly ISCs = bid power capacity × the lesser of bid storage duration and 8 hours × days in the month × monthly availability percentage, where the monthly availability percentage is 1 minus outage MWh divided by bid power capacity × hours in the month, as the standard agreement sets it. One hypothetical project; no strike price is applied, as none is given in NYSERDA’s announcement or results factsheet.

Contract security, from award to operation

Unless NYSERDA agreed otherwise in writing, a winner had to post contract security of USD 20,000 per MWac of bid power capacity within 30 days of the award notification date, in cash, certified funds or a letter of credit, or lose the award unless NYSERDA extended the deadline. A winner that then did not sign within 120 calendar days after NYSERDA provided the conformed draft, extended where NYSERDA was late, forfeited the security and had the award rescinded, and the project might not be eligible for future NYSERDA bulk storage solicitations.4, 5

After signing, the standard form raises the security in steps: a further USD 10,000 per MW of bid power capacity (the form measures MW in alternating current) within two years of the effective date, unless the seller instead shows an executed NYISO interconnection agreement, and a further USD 10,000 per MW no later than one year before the initial commercial operation milestone date. By our count, the steps come to USD 40,000 per MW of bid power capacity by one year before the initial commercial operation milestone date, or USD 30,000 where an interconnection agreement takes the place of the two-year step. An extension of the commercial operation milestone date needs a further USD 5,000 per MW of security, and is NYSERDA’s to grant in its sole discretion, only where construction has commenced and the delays are beyond the seller’s control.5

Under the form, NYSERDA refunds the security in full when the facility achieves Operational Certification at its Bid Power Capacity and Bid Storage Duration, and keeps all of it if the seller has not posted the security required under the two-year step by one year before the initial commercial operation milestone date, or misses the commercial operation milestone date without posting the extension security.5

What a bid had to clear, and a ceiling bidders could not see

Only projects found eligible in a first step could bid, and a bid had to meet minimum eligibility thresholds before it was evaluated on price and non-price factors. The thresholds included site control, interconnection, a permitting plan to enter operation by and development experience.4

Price then weighed 60% and non-price factors 40%: project viability and maturity 20%, electricity system value 10% and economic benefits 10%, with bids ranked in two separate orders, under 8 hours and 8 hours or more. The proposer also bid its own contract tenor, the period of ISC payments: at most 15 years for a lithium-ion project and 25 for any other.4

A bid whose strike price exceeded the Benchmark ISC Cost for its duration category, which the RFP defines as confidential maximum price levels and calls its maximum bid price metric, was ineligible; the proposer was not told of that finding, and its bid fee was not returned. The programme’s Implementation Plan says the maximum levelized net ISC cost that bids may not exceed is set confidentially between NYSERDA and the Department of Public Service for each solicitation. Bidders priced without knowing the ceiling.4, 6

The eight contracted projects

NYSERDA’s results factsheet lists them by region: seven have a duration of 4 hours and one of 8 hours, and their capacities add up to 950 MW.3

The eight contracted ISCRFP25-1 projects, all lithium-ion
ProjectCapacity (MW)Duration (hours)RegionCounty
Lighthouse Energy Storage1408Western New YorkChautauqua
Zenobe Burns1004Western New YorkAllegany
Eastwater Energy Storage1004Finger LakesMonroe
Key Capture Energy (KCE) NY 5944Mid-HudsonUlster
Blue Spruce Storage1334New York CityBronx
Palladium Storage1234New York CityBronx
Holtsville Energy Storage1104Long IslandSuffolk
Key Capture Energy (KCE) NY 371504Long IslandSuffolk

Source: NYSERDA’s results factsheet, tables by region.3

The second solicitation, and the first round’s prices

NYSERDA states that it intends to issue the second bulk energy storage solicitation by the end of 2026, the second of at least three bulk storage procurements using the ISC mechanism that the Public Service Commission’s order of directed it to run.2, 4, 5

For the first round, the RFP lets NYSERDA publish the executed agreements, or relevant terms in them, and says it will not entertain any request to redact price information. Published in full, the agreements would show the eight contracts’ strike prices.4

The battery storage guide sets this route beside the other ways storage is procured.

Sources (6)

  1. 1

    NYSERDA: press release, Awards Announced for New Bulk Energy Storage and Large-Scale Renewable Projects · Tier 1 · official · Verified

    Where in the document

    Date line (); opening paragraph (awards for eight new bulk energy storage projects); second paragraph (the result of NYSERDA’s first Bulk Energy Storage solicitation); section “New York’s First Bulk Energy Storage Awards”: first paragraph (950 MW once operational) and the paragraph after the list of projects (payments only from commercial operation; in service by the end of 2030, as the Commission’s 2024 order requires). The release also covers large-scale renewable awards, not used here.

  2. 2

    NYSERDA (New York State Energy Research and Development Authority): Bulk Energy Storage Solicitations page · Tier 1 · official · Verified

    Where in the document

    Section “2025 Bulk Energy Storage Solicitation (ISCRFP25-1)”, second sentence: bid proposals for 46 eligible projects, about 6 GW and 30 GWh. Section “2026 Bulk Energy Storage Solicitation”: the second solicitation intended by the end of 2026. Verification route for the round’s current status: this page, NYSERDA’s Bulk Energy Storage Contracts page (https://www.nyserda.ny.gov/All-Programs/Energy-Storage-Program/Developers-and-Contractors/Bulk-Storage-Incentives/Projects), NYSERDA’s newsroom and the records they link. A document missing from these pages is not proof that it is unpublished elsewhere. Live status check of (owner; carried out on the owner's behalf by ChatGPT, which opened the solicitations page and the Bulk Energy Storage Contracts page): the second bulk storage solicitation is still described as intended for release by the end of 2026 and none is listed on the solicitations page; ISCRFP25-1 has eight contracted projects totalling 950 MW, all listed, with storage durations from 4 to 8 hours; neither page publishes executed contract prices, which does not establish that no prices have been published elsewhere.

  3. 3

    NYSERDA: Bulk Energy Storage factsheet, 2025 Index Storage Credit Solicitation Results · Tier 1 · official · Verified

    Where in the document

    P. 1, “The 2025 Index Storage Credit Solicitation Results” (contracts executed with eight lithium-ion projects; 950 MW); p. 2, the five tables by region (project, county, technology, capacity in MW, duration in hours). The factsheet carries no date; its footer reads “LSR-bulkes25-fs-1-v1 9/26”.

  4. 4

    NYSERDA: Request for Proposals ISCRFP25-1, Long-Term Contracts to Purchase Index Storage Credits (ISCs), updated version · Tier 1 · official · Verified

    Where in the document

    Pages are the PDF’s, which match the printed ones. Version cited: the update of (original release ); §3.2.4 (Qualifying Governmental Support) was added by that update, and no other revision changes a cited passage. P. 2 (the two steps); p. 3 (no notice and no fee refund above the Benchmark ISC Cost); definitions (p. 7), Benchmark ISC Cost; §1 (p. 13), at least three procurements using the ISC mechanism; §1.2 (pp. 14–15), the ISC, the strike price and the reference price; §2.1.4 (p. 19), the tenor; p. 22, “maximum bid price metric”; §2.5.2 (p. 24), the CCIA’s 12% cap and floor; §2.6.1 (p. 26), the binding Strike Price; §3.1 and §3.2 (p. 27), the weights and the assumed 95% availability; §3.2 (p. 28), revised Strike Prices; §3.2.1.i to iii (pp. 28–30), the settlement and the RFP’s cap on payments to NYSERDA (conflict X-014); §3.2.2 (pp. 31–32), the Benchmark ISC Cost by duration, the Levelized Net ISC Cost on NYSERDA’s forecasts and the January 2027 delivery start; §3.2.3 and §3.2.4 (p. 33); §4 and Figure 1 (p. 34); §4.1, Table 3 (pp. 35–36), the thresholds; §6.1 (p. 55), the two rank orders, revised Strike Prices and counteroffers; §7.2 (p. 57), the award security; §7.4 (pp. 59–60), the execution deadline and the publication of executed agreements without redaction of price information. NYSERDA’s written answers to questions were not read.

  5. 5

    NYSERDA: ISCRFP25-1 Attachment A, Index Storage Credit Standard Form Agreement · Tier 1 · official · Verified

    Where in the document

    The published standard form (file SFA v11.18, linked from NYSERDA’s solicitations page; no date on its face; the RFP has NYSERDA posting the final agreement on ). The executed agreements were not read. Pages are the agreement’s printed numbers (the PDF page is the printed page plus two). Definitions, “Expected Governmental Grant Funding” (p. 7), “MW” (p. 10), “Qualifying Governmental Support” (p. 11), “Unexpected Governmental Grant Funding” (p. 13); §2.01, including (a) and (b) (pp. 13–14); §2.03 (p. 14); §2.06 (p. 15); §4.01(b) (p. 18); §4.03(c) (p. 19; conflict X-014); §4.05(a) to (d) (pp. 19–21); §5.02(b) (p. 22); §5.03 and §5.04 (p. 23); §5.05 (pp. 23–24); §15.01(a) to (c) (pp. 48–49); §15.02 (p. 49); §15.05(a) and §15.06(a) (p. 50); §15.06(b) (p. 51); §19.02 (p. 61); signature page (p. 63).

  6. 6

    NYSERDA: Bulk Energy Storage Program Implementation Plan, Case 18-E-0130 · Tier 1 · official · Verified

    Where in the document

    Pages are the plan’s printed numbers (the PDF page is the printed page plus three). Section 2.3 (p. 10): under “Limitation of Liability”, the limit |Monthly ISC Payment| ≤ Strike Price x Monthly ISCs Created, accepted by the 2025 BES Approving Order (conflict X-014); under “Maximum Bid Price Evaluation”, the confidential maximum levelized net ISC cost. Final plan of .

ListingMinds uses primary procurement, regulatory and contracting sources wherever available. How we work

How to cite

ListingMinds, “NYSERDA’s standard bulk storage contract settles against a market index, not the battery’s own revenue”, . https://www.listingminds.com/energy/field-notes/nyserda-bulk-storage-round

Decide which tenders are worth bidding for.

We'll email you once when access opens.

We'll send a confirmation link to this address. Nothing else is sent until you confirm.

Read our privacy notice.